Used machines for pallet shops, by make and model.

Find me a machine
Menu

Bulk or collated: choosing a pallet nailer

Bulk-fastener nailers cost more to buy and use cheaper loose nails; collated nailers cost less to buy but their coil or strip nails cost more, so the more pallets you build, the more a bulk machine makes sense.

Pneumatic nail guns loaded with collated nail strips on the gantry of an automated stringer nailer

Why the cost flips

A collated machine uses pneumatic nailing tools of the kind you can buy off the shelf, so the machine itself is simpler and cheaper. But collated nails, glued or wired into coils and strips, cost more per nail than loose bulk nails. A bulk machine has its own feeders and drivers to sort and drive loose nails, which costs more to build, and then feeds on cheaper nails for its whole life.

So the answer depends on how many nails you drive. A stringer pallet takes a lot of nails; multiply by your pallets a day and the working days in a year, and the difference in nail cost adds up.

Where each fits

A bulk automatic tandem nailing line in a pallet plant

At a few hundred pallets a day, collated machines are the usual choice: a Pallet Chief, a Rayco, a Woodpecker or a Universal. They are cheaper to buy and to move, and many run on 110 volts and air.

In the high hundreds and thousands a shift, bulk machines take over. The single-operator Viking Champion is rated at 500 to 600 a shift; the tandem lines go to 1,300, 1,800 and over 2,000 with two or three people.

Bulk and collated nailers compared, from Pallet Enterprise’s nailing guide
PointBulk fastenerCollated fastener
How it nailsHydraulic, mechanical or electric drivers fed loose nailsPneumatic tools fed coil or strip nails
Machine costHigherLower
Nail costLowerHigher
Makers in the guideViking, CAPE, Corali, GBN, Storti linesBronco, Rayco, Universal, Viper, Woodpecker, RT
Example outputViking Champion QC306: 500 to 600 a shift, one operatorViper Woody: up to 600 a shift, one operator
High endViking Turbo 606: upwards of 2,000 a shift, three operators—

Working it out for your shop

Get a current price for the nails each kind uses from your supplier, count the nails in the pallets you build most, and multiply by your volume. Set the yearly difference against the difference in machine price. We do not do that sum for you, because nail prices and pallet designs vary too much, but those are the only numbers you need.

Used machines change the answer. A used bulk machine can cost less than a new collated one, which pulls the break-even down. Check the drivers and feeders closely; our used nailer checklist goes through them.

Used machines change the sums

Buying used narrows the gap in purchase price, because used bulk machines sell for a fraction of new, while the nail bill stays the same whether the machine is new or old. So a used bulk machine can make sense at a volume where a new one would not. Against that, older bulk machines need more mechanical attention, and their parts are harder to find. A used collated machine is simpler to start up and simpler to keep running.

Count your pallets a week, find the price of the collated fasteners your guns would shoot and of bulk nails of the same size, and multiply. That one sum usually settles it.

Fixtures, sizes and changeovers

Nail cost is not the only difference. Bulk machines tend to be built for volume on a few sizes, with fixtures and feeders set up for each; changing pallet size takes longer. Collated machines and jigs are usually quicker to reset, which suits shops building many sizes in short runs. Count your sizes as well as your pallets.

Staffing matters too. A single-operator machine and a tandem line with two or three people deliver very different output per person, and labor is often the larger cost than nails.

Examples from the 2020 guide

Pallet Enterprise’s nailing guide gives a sense of the range. On the collated side, Viper’s Woody is rated at up to 600 pallets a shift with one operator, which is high for collated. On the bulk side, Viking’s Champion QC306 is rated at 500 to 600 with one operator and the Express 403 at about 1,300 with two. CAPE, Corali, GBN and Storti build bulk lines for plants above that. All of those figures are the makers’ own.

Our rule of thumb: if one collated machine already keeps a crew busy all shift and the nail invoices keep growing, price a used bulk machine.

Nail suppliers quote by the box or pallet; get both prices on the same day, in writing, for nails of identical length and shank.

Then factor downtime: jammed coils, misfeeds and worn drivers stop production differently on each machine type. Talk to owners of both, ideally shops building similar pallets at similar speeds, before deciding. Visit both kinds running. Spreadsheets beat guesswork.

Machines in this guide, with one model each as the trade guides list it
MachineFor exampleMaker’s figure
Pallet Chief nailersPallet Chief I, Compressed air onlyNot stated
Woodpecker nailersMMA Woodpecker, Pneumatic toolsNot stated
Viking nailing machinesViking Turbo 606, Three operatorsupwards of 2,000 a shift

Ask for bulk or collated

Tell us how many pallets a shift you build and which sizes. We will look for the machine that fits that volume.

Nailing machine

What do you need?
Add maker, model and power (optional)

We reply by email from info@usedpalletmachinery.com. Your details go only to people who can supply or buy the machine.